The Part-Time Creator Club

The Part-Time Creator Club

Share this post

The Part-Time Creator Club
The Part-Time Creator Club
I analysed the top 7 D2C brands on TikTok...

I analysed the top 7 D2C brands on TikTok...

...Here's what I found

Eve Arnold's avatar
Eve Arnold
Jul 09, 2025
∙ Paid
2

Share this post

The Part-Time Creator Club
The Part-Time Creator Club
I analysed the top 7 D2C brands on TikTok...
Share

If you’ve been following along on the journey to starting a business in 48 hours (update here), you’ll know that my focus this week has been on building a better, more compelling product page.

In an attempt to achieve that, I’ve been going deep into product pages to understand how they structure their offer and convert. Here’s what I’ve found and the pages I analysed:

  • hismile

  • Neuro

  • Truearth

  • Waterdrop

  • Dr Squatch

  • Youthfornia

  • Oatsovernight

1. Make it *incomparable*

I’ve purposely chosen brands that are completely different. We’ve got everything from laundry detergent to teeth whitener (to make sure I’m not just finding industry themes).

After analysing the pages for a little while, I realised something quite interesting. Every single product page was unique is the way it was delivered or existed in a category of one.

When you look at Neuro, or hismile or Waterdrop, it’s hard to understand what they should be priced at because they don’t look like anything else on the market. Take a look at Waterdrop below:

At first, I was confused about what this even was. After some reading, I realised it was a concentrated juice drink, in a cube. Here in the UK, a bottle of concentrate is £2 a bottle (a bottle that serves, I’d guess, 20 or so servings).

Here, this is a cube of concentrated flavour, £8.99 a box, which is 12 servings. Whichever way you look at it, it’s at least 4x the price of the market equivalent. But here’s the thing, there’s no market equivalent because a 1L bottle of juice is not the same as a juice cube or a ‘microdrink’ as Waterdrop calls it.

By being incomparable, you separate yourself.

1B. A new take on an existing category

This is sort of related to 1 and not actually about the product page (well, not exactly) so I’ve called it 1B.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Eve Arnold
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share